A quick glance through the online comment pages of The Landmark brings up two points. The first is that local parents and taxpayers are very concerned with the current referendum. The second, unfortunately, is that many of the people commenting are “trolls.”
I am not referring to a little monster that lives under a bridge and steals your goat if you don’t answer his three questions, and I’m not talking about the kind in caves either. Trolls, in this context, are (possibly green and hairy) people who lurk in the anonymous shadows of the Internet, plastering forums and comment sections with their unfiltered, and often untrue, opinions. Trolls can write what they want without having to be held accountable for the repercussions of their words.
To some, this is freedom of speech, while to others, it is a license to shove an opinion in others’ faces, completely forgoing etiquette, proper use of grammar, and correct spelling.
The reason the Landmark is so disturbing to me is not the presence of trolls, as anyone who spends any time online has had sufficient exposure to their kind, but the identity of these trolls. Because it’s a local paper, we can be sure that the trolls prowling around The Landmark are local as well. This sheds uneasy light on the previously dark faces of our trolls, revealing that they are our parents, neighbors, and bosses.
The example being set for us by our elders is that it’s ok to argue a point while foaming at the mouth or completely belligerent. Vicious ad hominem attacks and CONSTANT USE OF CAPITAL LETTERS are not the debating standard our parents should be setting in place for us, but sadly, it appears they are.
The point of this piece isn’t to support or condemn the referendum, but rather to urge the parents, grandparents, neighbors, and bosses in the area to take a step back and examine the way in which they conduct themselves online.
At its core, the lesson being taught here is that character isn’t important if you’re not wearing a name tag. Maybe local trolls are the ones who need to be involved with the “Character Counts” program here in the building.
Janet Kaluzny White • Apr 1, 2011 at 7:09 pm
Excellent work. As a grad of the Clarion editor-ship, I am so proud. I tangled with a few of these people at board meetings and in the papers in the late 80s, and I would encourage students to stay above the pettiness. The Landmark appeared to have an agenda re:RB 20 something years ago, and it does not seem to improve. Keep in mind that the Landmark once entertained a debate re: the appropriateness of peonies in public spaces.
Diane Hettasch • Mar 11, 2011 at 3:40 pm
I think you brought up a great point and should submit it to the Landmark also. Each and every one of us likes to be treated with respect and should treat others with respect. I think respect is in short supply these days. Beautifully written and good point!
Steve Yurek • Mar 11, 2011 at 1:53 pm
Well said Trent! If I could write that well and express myself that clearly….I wouldn’t have had to become a math teacher. Reading your article was an outstanding part of my day………….unlike reading the Landmark trolls. Ew!
Adam Gibbons • Mar 11, 2011 at 1:35 pm
I enjoyed reading this article – loved the CAPITAL LETTERS reference in particular… that seems to be the most effective way for those “trolls” to get their ‘points’ (and believe me I use that term loosely) across. A refreshing perspective.
Jeremy Heer • Mar 11, 2011 at 12:51 pm
Couldn’t agree more, Trent. Good work here.
Melissa Gordon • Mar 11, 2011 at 12:45 pm
Trent,
Very well done. Your voice deserves to be heard by those that really need to hear it. You should seriously consider sending this in to the Landmark!
Darcy Lewis • Mar 11, 2011 at 11:32 am
Very impressive commentary, Trent. Thank you! You’re right that many adults in this community are failing you teens and owe you all much better than that. Not to mention themselves, their families and the hardworking teachers who undoubtedly labored to instill a sense of proper respect and a grasp of the mechanics of spelling, punctuation and grammar.
Please do consider sending this to The Landmark. Your voice deserves to be heard.
Dan Bonarigo • Mar 11, 2011 at 10:54 am
Very well written! This should be sent to the Landmark.
David Monti • Mar 11, 2011 at 10:44 am
Well said Trent…